Essex on Lake Champlain
\"Essex
  • About
    • Essex, New York (Town)
      • Essex Maps
      • Essex, New York Weather
      • Town of Essex Government
      • Close
    • Essex on Lake Champlain (Blog)
      • Contributors
      • Sponsors
      • Testimonials
      • Get Involved
      • Close
    • Close
  • Books
  • Blog
  • Calendar
    • Add an Event
    • Upcoming Events
    • Close
  • Essex on Lake Champlain
  • Connect
    • Social Media
      • Facebook
      • Twitter
      • Google +
      • Pinterest
      • YouTube
      • Flickr
    • Newsletters
    • GET INVOLVED
    • CONTACT
        • Your Name (required)

          Your Email (required)

          Subject (required)

          Your Message

      • Close
    • Shop
    • Search
        • Search
          • Close
        • Categories
            • Agriculture (513)
            • Architecture (74)
            • Arts (319)
            • Business (120)
            • Daily Doodle (62)
            • Dining (151)
            • Doodle Quotes (5)
            • Doodlebomb (3)
            • Education (288)
            • Entertainment (337)
            • Environment (27)
            • Essex Doodles (62)
            • Events (1532)
            • Exercise (54)
            • Government (245)
            • Health & Wellness (132)
            • Heritage (384)
            • History (174)
            • Hyperlocal (26)
            • Landscape (35)
            • Lifestyle (195)
            • Lodging (16)
            • Music (255)
            • Nature (247)
            • News (1084)
            • Nightlife (18)
            • Obituary (9)
            • Opinion (44)
            • Outdoors (176)
            • People (112)
            • Philanthropy (68)
            • Real Estate (3)
            • Recreation (204)
            • Resources (7)
            • Services (7)
            • Shopping (89)
            • Sports (21)
            • Transportation (70)
            • Worship (17)
          • Close
        • Archives
            • June 2018 (21)
            • May 2018 (30)
            • April 2018 (28)
            • March 2018 (30)
            • February 2018 (31)
            • January 2018 (26)
            • December 2017 (23)
            • November 2017 (25)
            • October 2017 (22)
            • September 2017 (32)
            • August 2017 (35)
            • July 2017 (30)
            • June 2017 (30)
            • May 2017 (35)
            • April 2017 (31)
            • March 2017 (33)
            • February 2017 (30)
            • January 2017 (35)
            • December 2016 (30)
            • November 2016 (37)
            • October 2016 (43)
            • September 2016 (53)
            • August 2016 (49)
            • July 2016 (59)
            • June 2016 (70)
            • May 2016 (57)
            • April 2016 (64)
            • March 2016 (69)
            • February 2016 (56)
            • January 2016 (46)
            • December 2015 (39)
            • November 2015 (43)
            • October 2015 (61)
            • September 2015 (57)
            • August 2015 (61)
            • July 2015 (54)
            • June 2015 (41)
            • May 2015 (67)
            • April 2015 (66)
            • March 2015 (72)
          • Load More
          • Close
        • Contact us
          • CONTACT US

              Your Name (required)

              Your Email (required)

              Subject (required)

              Your Message

            • Close
        • Close
      • Log In
        • Log Into Calendar
        • Log Into Blog
        • Close
      • Skip to primary navigation
      • Skip to main content
      • Skip to primary sidebar
      • Skip to footer

      Essex on Lake Champlain

      Essex, New York Community Blog Since 2011

      • Lifestyle
        • Agriculture
          • CSAs in Essex, NY
            • Essex Farm
            • Full and By Farm
          • Farmstead Catering
          • The Hub on the Hill
          • Reber Rock Farm
        • Outdoors
          • Champlain Area Trails (CATS)
          • Pok-O-MacCready Outdoor Education Center
        • Entertainment
          • Champlain Valley Film Series
          • Whallonsburg Grange Hall
        • Arts
          • Adirondack Art Association
          • Essex Community Concerts
          • Champlain Valley Film Series
          • Essex Poetry Open Mic
        • Music
          • Essex Community Concerts
        • Shopping
        • Recreation
          • Champlain Area Trails (CATS)
        • Health & Wellness
          • Lake Champlain Yoga & Wellness
          • NEW Health
        • Nature
          • Champlain Area Trails (CATS)
        • Education
          • CFES Brilliant Pathways
          • Pok-O-MacCready Outdoor Education Center
        • Nightlife
        • Worship
      • Events
        • Christmas in Essex
        • Downtown Essex Day
        • Fourth of July in Essex, NY
      • Dining
        • Chez Lin & Rays
        • Essex Ice Cream Cafe
        • Essex Inn on the Adirondack Coast
        • Farmstead Catering
        • Old Dock Restaurant
        • The Pink Pig Cafe
      • Lodging
        • Essex Inn on the Adirondack Coast
        • The Cupola House and Cottage
      • Transportation
        • Essex-Charlotte Ferry
      • Heritage
        • Architecture
          • Essex, New York Architecture: A Doodler’s Field Guide
        • Historic Essex
        • History
        • People
        • Government
          • Essex Post Office
          • Town of Essex Government
        • Vintage Essex Trivia
        • Vintage Essex Artifacts
      • Directory
        • Adirondack Art Association
        • Champlain Area Trails (CATS)
        • CFES Brilliant Pathways
        • The Cupola House and Cottage
        • Essex-Charlotte Ferry
        • Essex Farm
        • Essex Ice Cream Cafe
        • Essex Initiatives
        • Essex Post Office
        • Farmstead Catering
        • Full and By Farm
        • Historic Essex
        • Lake Champlain Yoga & Wellness
        • NEW Health
        • Pedal Power
        • Reber Rock Farm
        • The Hub on the Hill
        • Town of Essex Government
        • Whallonsburg Grange Hall
      • Show Search
      Hide Search
      You are here: Home / Landscape / The Wildfire Next Time

      The Wildfire Next Time

      September 14, 2015 By John Davis Leave a Comment

      Charred Stumps: Split Rock Wild Forest ground fire (Source: virtualDavis)
      Charred Stumps: Split Rock Wild Forest ground fire (Source: virtualDavis)

      We may not need to brace ourselves for “The Big One”, as do San Francisco and Sanford & Son, but we should prepare for worsening disturbances. Wildfire can be a natural disturbance of unpredictably enhancing qualities; but in a climate chaos century, in a fragmented landscape, with invading exotic organisms, wildfire may become a still unrulier beast. We would do well, as residents of New York’s great Adirondack Park, to ponder fires of the future and study possible alternatives to the present state policy of zero tolerance – full suppression of all wildfires.

      Champlain Valley… [forests] probably did burn occasionally before European settlers altered natural patterns, and the may want to burn more, with future droughts.

      Fire is a powerful force, which may prove more powerful than its wielder when used as a tool. Yet fighting every little fire may mean inviting an eventual conflagration that no human work can squelch. Presently, most of Adirondack Park grows moist forests that seldom if ever burn under natural circumstances, but in the Champlain and Saint Lawrence Valleys grow some drier forests that probably did burn occasionally before European settlers altered natural patterns, and they may want to burn more, with future droughts.

      Such were the thoughts of George Davis and me a month after Split Rock Wild Forest ground fire as we strode the newly cut trail to the acre and a half atop a rocky hill west of Orebed Point that burned in early August. The fire apparently was ignited by a lightning strike, as George confirmed when he found this White Pine near the summit with a long linear scar down the trunk and charred roots.

      Lightning Strike: Split Rock Wild Forest ground fire (Source: virtualDavis)
      Lightning Strike: Split Rock Wild Forest ground fire (Source: virtualDavis)

      As soon as the fire was reported, on August 6 or 7, New York Department of Environmental Conservation sent to the trailhead on Lakeshore Road many trucks of personnel and equipment to fight the fire, and even had a chopper flying overhead. (Seeing and hearing the assembled force, I initially thought: Oh bother, another Dannemora outbreak!) Fire fighters cut a trail to the burning hill-top, drove in tools on all-terrain vehicles, and successfully stopped the fire.

      Some forests are meant to burn, and… suppressing small fires may mean inviting bigger, more dangerous blazes in the future.

      Was this the right response, though, and will prompt suppression be the best response next time a wildfire starts in the West Champlain Hills? The weather this summer – unusually wet first half, unusually dry second – hints at possible future changes in natural disturbance regimes. Should DEC close and rehabilitate the new trail, or risk soil erosion and exotic species invasions to let it remain open as a foot-path to a rare site? Might a mechanized response (apparently here including ATVs, chainsaws, and a helicopter) do more damage to the forest than a wildfire generally does?

      I suspect so, and I suspect our forests will soon suffer and our own communities may eventually pay a high price if we continue to view wildfire as an enemy. Some forests are meant to burn, and (though research is not complete in our area) the composition of plant communities can be altered, and biological diversity diminished, where natural disturbances are suppressed. If lessons from the conifer forests of the West and Southeast apply to deciduous/conifer forests of the Northeast in a warming climate, suppressing small fires may mean inviting bigger, more dangerous blazes in the future.

      Re-sprouting Stump: Split Rock Wild Forest ground fire (Source: virtualDavis)
      Re-sprouting Stump: Split Rock Wild Forest ground fire (Source: virtualDavis)

      DEC is not to blame for any of this; the Department is merely implementing policies long ago put in place – put in place before fire ecology or climate change was fully understood. Indeed, apart from its use of mechanized equipment, DEC appears to have been environmentally sensitive in its squelching of the recent fire. Trampling and erosion at the burn site do not look much greater than one might find in an area that had been allowed to burn. Already, just a month or so after the fire, oaks, Pitch Pine, blueberry, serviceberry, dogbane, and other plants are re-sprouting. The fire burned spottily, like most natural fires do, creating a mosaic of varying conditions, from charred to untouched, with plenty of plants still alive.

      Re-sprouting Oak Tree Seedling: Split Rock Wild Forest ground fire (Source: virtualDavis)
      Re-sprouting Oak Tree Seedling: Split Rock Wild Forest ground fire (Source: virtualDavis)

      My own inclination (from rambling these hills extensively but also exploring many forests, burned and unburned, in the West and South) is to let natural, lightning-ignited fires burn in wildlands, but suppress human-caused fires and blazes that get too near homes. In any case, in a time when we meddlesome humans are altering not only biotic communities but the very climate that molded these life forms, we would do well to reconsider our zero tolerance attitude toward wildfire. I urge my fellow Adirondack residents to ask the DEC to do a thorough ecological assessment of wildfire policy on Forest Preserve lands in Adirondack and Catskill Parks, in view of a destabilizing climate. I urge neighbors not to build new houses in the forest and to take precautions (like metal roofs, storing combustibles safely, clearing kindling around house …) for those homes already built in the woods. If we learn to live more compatibly with wild Nature, perhaps we can welcome the wildfire next time as a cleansing and diversifying force.

      Related articles
      • Where is the Split Rock Wildway? (www.essexonlakechamplain.com)
      • Split Rock Wildway: A Critical Wildlife Corridor (www.essexonlakechamplain.com)
      • Cougar Watch Update from Protect the Adirondacks! (www.essexonlakechamplain.com)

      Share this:

      • Facebook
      • Twitter
      • Pinterest
      • Email
      • More
      • Print
      • LinkedIn
      • Pocket
      • Reddit
      • Tumblr

      Filed Under: Landscape, Nature, Outdoors, Resources Tagged With: Adirondack Mountains, Adirondack Park, DEC, fire, Forest fire, John Davis, New York Department of Environmental Conservation, Split Rock Forest, Split Rock Wild Forest

      About John Davis

      John Davis is a wildways scout, editor, and writer. He lives with his family in Split Rock Wildway, where he care-takes Hemlock Rock Wildlife Sanctuary when not roaming farther afield. He is a volunteer land steward for Eddy Foundation, which has secured and opened to the public about 3,000 acres in the eastern Adirondacks; a board member of Champlain Area Trails and other outdoor/wildlife organizations; a co-founder of Wildlands Network; and is the Executive Director of The Rewilding Institute. He is the editor of many conservation publications and author of Big, Wild, and Connected: Scouting an Eastern Wildway from Florida to Quebec—about his 7,600-mile traverse of the proposed Eastern Wildway in 2011. His 5,000-mile traverse of the Rocky Mountains from Sonora, Mexico, to British Columbia, Canada, is featured in the film Born to Rewild. His second book, Split Rock Wildway: Scouting the Adirondack Park’s Most Diverse Wildlife Corridor is a rambling look at some of the charismatic and enigmatic wildlife thriving in the wooded hills and adjacent waterways linking Lake Champlain with the High Peaks.

      Reader Interactions

      Leave a Reply Cancel reply

      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

      This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

      Primary Sidebar

      Split Rock Wildway: Scouting the Adirondack Park’s Most Diverse Wildlife Corridor 

      Essex, New York Architecture: A Doodler's Field Guide

      View all Essex Editions books...

      Follow Essex, NY on FacebookFollow Essex, NY on TwitterFollow Essex, NY on PinterestFollow Essex, NY on YouTubeFollow Essex, NY on FlickrFollow Essex, NY on RSS

      Search

      Top 10 Contributors

      • Katie Shepard (585)
      • Geo Davis (394)
      • Whallonsburg Grange Hall (231)
      • Essex Farm (205)
      • Champlain Area Trails (CATS) (198)
      • Olive Alexander (190)
      • Sara Kurak (165)
      • Tom Mangano (142)
      • Fort Ticonderoga (142)
      • Lakeside School (116)

      Upcoming Events

      Click to enlarge.

      Essex Community Potluck

      January 26 @ 6:00 pm At St. John's Church

      Essex Community Potluck Tuesdays 6pm Join us for food and friendly conversation. Please bring a potl… [Continue Reading]

      Click to enlarge.

      Newman Center Film Series-on-Tour: THE CREEPING FLESH

      January 30 @ 7:00 pm At Plattsburgh Days Inn

      The Newman Center Film Series-on-Tour will stop at Plattsburgh’s Days Inn (formerly… [Continue Reading]

      Click to enlarge.

      Essex Community Church Sunday Service

      January 31 @ 11:00 am At Essex Community Church

      In the spirit of fellowship and community that defines us, we welcome everyone who wants to celebrat… [Continue Reading]

      Click to enlarge.

      Essex Community Suppers

      January 31 @ 4:00 pm

      Join us for Community Supper — All are Welcome! Sundays, 4-5:30PM Free farm-to-table suppers — t… [Continue Reading]

      Footer

      Resources & Policies

      • About Essex on Lake Champlain
      • About Essex, New York
      • Essex, NY Weather
      • Disclosure Policy
      • Privacy Policy
      • Submit a Story
      • Contact Us

      Popular Essex, NY Searches

      • Essex, NY
      • Essex, New York
      • Essex on Lake Champlain
      • Essex Charlotte ferry
      • Essex ferry schedule
      • Essex Charlotte ferry schedule
      • Full and By Farm
      • Essex Farm
      • timber rattlesnake
      • Essex NY fireworks
      • Christmas in Essex, NY
      • Champlain Area Trails

      Local Links

      • Adirondack Art Association
      • Champlain Area Trails
      • Champlain Valley Film Society
      • Essex Community Concerts
      • Essex Theatre Company
      • Historic Essex
      • Rosslyn Redux
      • The Crater Club
      • Town of Essex Information
      • Whallonsburg Grange Hall

      Copyright © 2021 Essex Editions

      loading Cancel
      Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
      Email check failed, please try again
      Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.